How To Manage Poor Performance

How To Manage Poor Performance

At some point in your career as a manager, you’re going to have to manage a poor performing employee. You’ll have to deal with that employee who just isn’t pulling his or her weight. You’ll have to talk with that team mate who just can’t keep up. But before you jump right into the conversation, perhaps the best thing you can do is step back and observe the situation. Because if you understand the cause of the poor performance, you will be better able to resolve it…and maybe even able to unleash the latent talent of that employee that just hasn’t been shown yet.

In thinking about poor performance, it’s helpful to divide the causes into two broad categories. (We’ll sub-divide a bit later). There are primarily two reasons for poor performance. The first is the system—meaning the overall organization, the work environment, the way different parts of the organization interact, the way performance is being tracked, and a host of other elements that comprise what surrounds an individual worker. The second category, therefore, is the employees themselves.

It’s helpful to remember the wise thoughts of W. Edwards Deming, the legendary organizational psychologist. Deming had a principle he called the 85/15 rule. What the rule meant was the 85% of an employees’ performance was determined by the system the employee worked within. Only 15% was the actually employee. That means than if you’re looking at a poor performer and wondering what to do, look around first and make sure it’s not an environmental factor that’s diminishing performance. 

As Deming liked to say “A bad system will beat a good person every time.” 

So make sure they have the resources they need. Make sure coworkers are working well together. And honestly, make sure that you’ve made your expectations clear. A lot of poor performance can actually be explained by good employees working hard to achieve what they THINK are management’s objectives, only to find out too late they were working on the wrong tasks.

If it’s not the system, then poor performers themselves. But even here, it may or may not be what we would fairly label an individual’s “fault.” Inside of individual performance, there are many factors. Poor performance could be a capability issue, meaning your people lack the knowledge, skills, or abilities to do the job. And hence your role is to find training or find a better position for them. It could be a communication issue, meaning they’re not interacting properly with the rest of the team (and it is their “fault”) but they simply need some interpersonal skills development. Or, it could be a motivation issue. Perhaps they’re burned out of doing the same projects over and over again and need something that will stretch and grow them. Perhaps they’re not responding to the usual company incentives and you need to help find something else they’d work toward. 

Or, perhaps they really don’t want to work and then you have to have the difficult conversation of inviting them to be successful somewhere else. But as Deming would remind us, that’s likely only the case about 15% of the time.

Regardless of what conversation you have to have, the best thing you can do is make sure you’ve got a clear picture of what conversation that is. Don’t rush into meeting with a poor performance and assume it’s a motivation issue when the employee is thinking it’s a systems issue. Get objectively clear on what’s causing the poor performance and, if you’re not, then make your first conversation one of offering help in finding out what’s wrong.

Poor managers deal with poor performance by assuming the cause. Good managers find out first and adjust accordingly.

This article originally appeared as an episode of the DailyBurk, which you can follow on YouTubeFacebook, LinkedInTwitter, or Instagram.

Thanks for reading. You can get more actionable ideas in my popular email newsletter. Each week, I share educational (and entertaining) videos, articles, and podcasts that will help you and your team do your best work ever. Over 40,000 leaders just like you have subscribed. Enter your email now and join us.


About the author

David Burkus is an organizational psychologist, keynote speaker, and bestselling author of five books on leadership and teamwork.

Recommended Reading

What Great Managers Do Daily [4 Key Actions]

Managers make the difference. Middle managers especially play a crucial role in employee engagement and performance. However, many managers lack proper preparation for their role, and companies often fail to invest in robust leadership training. Great managers understand that their actions have a direct impact on their team’s success. In particular, great managers improve their […]

Do We Really Need Managers?

There have been SO many articles and books about this idea of flat organizations. No managers, no bosses, just passionate people solving problems and collaborating at ease. Sounds great, right? Well, not if you’re a manager, obviously. But the concept sounds great, right? Less oversight, more trust, more autonomy, we all want that! What these […]

Is Remote Work The New Normal?

Is remote working the new normal? Yes, but also no. It’s a little complicated. Let’s recap. On January 1st of this year, most CEOs of most organizations would not believe that their employees could work from home five days a week and still be productive. There was a rise in the remote work movement years […]

Scroll to Top